• About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Friday, May 27, 2022
The Iowa Torch
  • Home
  • State Government
  • Federal Government
  • Local Government
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • State Government
  • Federal Government
  • Local Government
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Opinion
The Iowa Torch
The Iowa Torch
No Result
View All Result
Home Education

8th Circuit Court Partially Reinstates Iowa’s Mask Mandate Ban in Schools

8th Circuit Court Panel: "Plaintiffs are entitled to a preliminary injunction but the district court abused its discretion by entering an overbroad one."

Shane Vander HartbyShane Vander Hart
January 25, 2022
in Education, Federal Government
Reading Time: 3 mins read
Des Moines Public Schools Says Only State Can Mandate Masks

Kindergarten Jumpstart on Thursday, August 12, 2021 at the Downtown School in Des Moines, Iowa.

RELATED POSTS

Eighth Circuit Court lifts preliminary injunction of Iowa mask mandate ban

Ernst introduces bill to move federal agencies out of D.C.

Ernst, Grassley vote against bill codifying abortion rights

DES MOINES, Iowa – A two members of a three-judge panel consisting of Judges Duane Benton, Jane Kelly, and Ralph Erickson, in the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals, ruled to vacate a district court’s injunction of Iowa’s mask mandate ban in part because it was too broad.

Judges Benton and Kelly ruled that the Plaintiffs, Arc of Iowa, and parents of disabled children who joined the lawsuit against Gov. Kim Reynolds, Iowa Department of Education Director Ann Lebo, and ten Iowa school districts are entitled to a preliminary injunction stating that mask requirements are reasonable accommodations required by federal disability law to protect the rights of the plaintiffs’ children.

They noted that the injunction imposed by U.S. District Court Judge Robert Pratt “sweeps more broadly than necessary to remedy Plaintiffs’ injuries.” 

On the last day of the 2021 legislative session, the Iowa Legislature passed, and Gov. Kim Reynolds signed a bill prohibiting schools, cities, and counties from implementing mask mandates. Pratt’s ruling effectively prohibited the state from enforcing the mask mandate ban in any school district.

“Plaintiffs are entitled to a preliminary injunction but the district court abused its discretion by entering an overbroad one. This Court reverses as to the scope of the injunction. An injunction must be tailored to remedy the specific harm suffered,” Judge Benton wrote in the majority’s opinion. 

ADVERTISEMENT

“Plaintiffs are not harmed by the absence of mask requirements at schools their children do not attend. Further, to the extent that some schools in Iowa do not encounter anyone whose disabilities require the schools to make others wear masks, Section 280.31 may prohibit those schools from imposing mask requirements without violating federal disability law,” he added. 

“By barring Defendants Reynolds and Lebo from enforcing Section 280.31 in all contexts, the Court prevented them from enforcing Iowa’s law against schools that encounter no one with disabilities that require masks as a reasonable accommodation. This sweeps broader than the relief necessary to remedy Plaintiffs’ injuries and is an abuse of discretion,” Benton’s opinion reads.

Judge Erickson wrote in a dissenting opinion that an injunction was premature. 

“(B)y conclusively determining that mask requirements are reasonable accommodations required by federal disability law, the district court broadens our law and fails to give appropriate weight to the requirement that ‘governmental policies implemented through legislation and developed through presumptively reasoned democratic processes are entitled to a higher degree of deference and should not be enjoined lightly,'” he wrote.

“I do not believe face masks are the equivalent of wheelchair ramps and I do not believe that we should automatically excuse exhaustion and assume the process or relief would be inadequate,” Erickson argued. “This case is about children’s ability to receive instruction while attending school. Courts should not act so quickly to intervene in the resolution of conflicts which arise in the daily operation of school systems.” 

The 8th Circuit Court ruling remands the case back to Judge Pratt to narrowly tailor his injunction to apply to the plaintiffs’ schools.

Two school districts – West Des Moines Community Schools and Urbandale Community Schools – have already dropped their mask mandates following the ruling. 

Read the ruling below:

CTA8 mask opinion
Tags: 8th Circuit Court of AppealsArc of IowaDuane BentonJane Kellymask mandate banRalph EricksonRobert PrattU.S. District Court for the Southern District of IowaUrbandale Community SchoolsWest Des Moines Community Schools
ShareTweetShare
ADVERTISEMENT
Previous Post

Mohr Files Legislation Making Retirement Income Tax-Free in Iowa House

Next Post

Klein Announces He Will Not Run for Re-Election to the Iowa House in 2022

Shane Vander Hart

Shane Vander Hart

Shane Vander Hart is the editor of The Iowa Torch.

Related Posts

children sitting in the classroom
Federal Government

Eighth Circuit Court lifts preliminary injunction of Iowa mask mandate ban

May 19, 2022
Video reveals Des Moines Metro school officials discussing skirting anti-CRT law
Education

Video reveals Des Moines Metro school officials discussing skirting anti-CRT law

April 22, 2022
Chapman Proposes Constitutional Amendment on Life
State Government

Chapman Plans to Address ‘Obscene’ Reading Material in Public Schools

November 29, 2021
State Government

Iowa’s Mask Mandate Ban Heads to 8th Circuit Court of Appeals

October 12, 2021
State Officials Release Back-to-School Guidance for COVID-19
Education

(Updated) Several Iowa School Districts Reinstate Mask Mandates

September 23, 2021
State Government

Federal Judge Temporarily Halts Iowa’s Mask Mandate Ban

September 14, 2021
Next Post
Klein Announces He Will Not Run for Re-Election to the Iowa House in 2022

Klein Announces He Will Not Run for Re-Election to the Iowa House in 2022

School Choice Bill Creating Education Savings Accounts Advances in Iowa Senate

Sign-Up For Our Daily Updates

Get The Iowa Torch right in your inbox!

Please wait...

Thank you for signing up!

Recommended Articles

Reynolds Extends Regulatory Relief for COVID-19 Recovery

Reynolds Extends Regulatory Relief for COVID-19 Recovery

April 30, 2021

School Choice Bill Creating Education Savings Accounts Advances in Iowa Senate

January 26, 2022
Iowa City Schools Reports 4.7% of Students Are Quarantined Due to COVID-19

Iowa City Schools Reports 4.7% of Students Are Quarantined Due to COVID-19

April 8, 2021

Popular Stories

  • Reynolds Launches New Teacher and Paraeducator Registered Apprenticeship

    Reynolds targets two more Republican state representatives

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Five Iowa House Republicans took money from teachers’ union PAC

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Reynolds endorses two pro-school choice Iowa House candidates

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Iowa House will not vote on school choice bill this year

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Freeman files to run in Iowa House District 46

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

The Iowa Torch

The Iowa Torch​ is a for-profit, news organization that focuses on political news as it relates to Iowans

Categories

  • Education
  • Federal Government
  • Iowa History
  • Local Government
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • State Government
  • Uncategorized

Newsletter

Please wait...

Thank you for signing up!

© 2022 The Iowa Torch, a publication of 4:15 Communications, LLC.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • State Government
  • Federal Government
  • Local Government
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Opinion

© 2022 The Iowa Torch, a publication of 4:15 Communications, LLC.