• About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Tuesday, July 5, 2022
The Iowa Torch
  • Home
  • State Government
  • Federal Government
  • Local Government
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • State Government
  • Federal Government
  • Local Government
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Opinion
The Iowa Torch
The Iowa Torch
No Result
View All Result
Home State Government

Iowa Supreme Court rules there is no right to abortion in state constitution

The Iowa Supreme Court upheld the state's 24-hour waiting period for an abortion and overturned its 2018 decision ruling abortion to be a fundamental right in Iowa's Constitution.

Shane Vander HartbyShane Vander Hart
June 17, 2022
in State Government
Reading Time: 5 mins read
Iowa Supreme Court rules there is no right to abortion in state constitution

The Justices of the Iowa Supreme Court. Front row, left to right: Justice Brent Appel, Chief Justice Susan Christensen, and Justice Thomas Waterman.
Back row, left to right: Justice Dana Oxley, Justice Edward Mansfield, Justice Christopher McDonald, and Justice Matthew McDermott.

DES MOINES, Iowa – The Iowa Supreme Court issued a ruling on Friday upholding the state’s 24-hour waiting period for an abortion. It also overturned its 2018 Planned Parenthood v. Reynolds decision finding abortion to be a fundamental right in Iowa’s Constitution.

The justices decided five to two, with Chief Justice Susan Christensen and Justice Brent Appel in dissent, to uphold the waiting period law and to overturn the 2018 decision. (Correction: We originally reported that Chief Justice Christensen joined the majority in upholding the 24-hour waiting period law, but dissented overturning the 2018 law .However, she only joined the majority rejecting single issue argument – see the opinion below – made by the plaintiffs, but in her separate opinion stated she found the law unconstitutional since she was unwilling to overturn the 2018 decision because of stare decisive. We regret the error.)

The case, Planned Parenthood v. Reynolds (PPH III, the 2018 case is PPH II), is remanded back to the district court.

Justice Edward Mansfield wrote the court’s opinion. 

“Although we overrule (the 2018 decision) and thus reject the proposition that there is a fundamental right to an abortion in Iowa’s Constitution subjecting abortion regulation to strict scrutiny, we do not at this time decide what constitutional standard should replace it,” he wrote in the introduction.

Mansfield later wrote that the 2018 decision “lacks textual and historical support. It is doctrinally inconsistent with prior Iowa jurisprudence concerning family rights that followed a balancing approach. Its rhetoric is one-sided. Its constitutional footing is unsound.”

The Iowa Supreme Court also acknowledged the expected Supreme Court decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Center case that could overturn Roe v. Wade and Planned Parenthood v. Casey. 

“(W)e are not blind to the fact that an important abortion case is now pending in the United States Supreme Court,” Mansfield wrote. “That case could alter the federal constitutional landscape established by Roe and Casey. While we zealously guard our ability to interpret the Iowa Constitution independently of the Supreme Court’s interpretations of the Federal Constitution, the opinion (or opinions) in that case may provide insights that we are currently lacking.”

Mansfield wrote that the status quo is the undue burden test provided in the 1992 Supreme Court decision in Planned Parenthood v. Casey. That standard was applied in the 2015 Planned Parenthood v. Iowa Board of Medicine ruling that struck down the Board’s telemedicine abortion ban. 

He said for now that is the governing standard that the district court must use.

Justice Matthew McDermott disagreed that Casey’s undue burden test should be the court’s governing standard. 

“I dissent from my colleagues’ remand directing the district court to apply an ‘undue burden’ standard, subject (apparently) to the standard being ‘litigated further’ by the parties. In my view, we should emphatically reject—not recycle—Casey’s moribund undue burden test and instead direct the district court to apply the rational basis test to the plaintiffs’ constitutional challenge,” he wrote in a separate opinion.

“The ‘inherently standardless nature’ of the undue burden test opens wide the gate for judges to inject their own policy preferences in deciding whether a particular restriction creates an undue burden to getting an abortion,” he added.

Christensen, who did not join the majority in overturning the court’s 2018 opinion, said she could not do so out of respect for stare decisis. 

“I do not believe any special justification ‘over and above the [majority’s] belief ‘that the precedent was wrongly decided’ warrants such a swift departure from the court’s 2018 decision,” she wrote in a separate opinion. 

Appel disagreed with upholding the 24-hour waiting period and overturning their 2018 decision. In his separate opinion, he said, “This jurisprudence of doubt will plainly impact many women and the men who support them.”

Governor Kim Reynolds applauded the ruling.

“Today’s ruling is a significant victory in our fight to protect the unborn. The Iowa Supreme Court reversed its earlier 2018 decision, which made Iowa the most abortion-friendly state in the country. Every life is sacred and should be protected, and as long as I’m governor that is exactly what I will do,” she said.

Iowa Senate Majority Leader Jack Whitver, R-Ankeny, said Friday’s ruling was a victory for the separation of powers. 

“The Supreme Court’s decision on single subject strengthened the legislature’s independence and constitutionally protected powers to write the laws of this state,” he said. “Undoing a constitutional right manufactured simply by judicial fiat and solidifying the legislature’s independence is a remarkable display of judicial restraint.”

U.S. Rep. Randy Feenstra, R-Iowa, who served in the Iowa Senate until 2021, applauded the ruling. 

“In Iowa, we are proud to stand for life. Today’s decision by the Iowa Supreme Court underscores our commitment to protecting innocent life in Iowa. As a father and a Christian, I am committed to working with my pro-life colleagues in Congress to enact the same pro-life policies that we have championed in Iowa at the federal level,” he said.

Planned Parenthood North Central States expressed disappointment in the ruling and reminded Iowans that abortion is still legal.

“I want to be very clear that abortion is still safe and legal in Iowa, even after today’s Court decision,” said Sarah Stoesz, president and CEO of Planned Parenthood North Central States. “We are deeply disappointed that the Iowa Supreme Court is abandoning women in spite of overwhelming support for abortion access.”

ACLU of Iowa Legal Director Rita Bettis Austen called the decision a “devastating and shocking reversal.”

“But abortion remains legal in Iowa and we will continue to fight to challenge the two-appointment, minimum 24-hour mandatory delay law under the undue burden standard that the Court declined to overrule today,” she said.

Read the opinion below:

210856_404B59267AF78

RELATED POSTS

Reynolds to ask Iowa Courts to reconsider recent abortion rulings

Post Roe, state elected officials pledge abortion debate in Iowa

Iowa to allocate $100M in federal funding for school safety

ADVERTISEMENT
Tags: abortionabortion debateACLU of IowaBrent AppelEdward MansfieldIowa Supreme CourtKim ReynoldsMatthew McDermottPlanned ParenthoodPlanned Parenthood v. ReynoldsSusan Christensen
ShareTweetShare
ADVERTISEMENT
Previous Post

Axne attacks Nunn in first campaign ad

Next Post

Miller-Meeks: Holding the Chinese Communist Party accountable

Shane Vander Hart

Shane Vander Hart

Shane Vander Hart is the editor of The Iowa Torch.

Related Posts

Schultz: Governor Highlights Successes in Western Iowa
State Government

Reynolds to ask Iowa Courts to reconsider recent abortion rulings

June 29, 2022
the united states capitol building in washington
Federal Government

Iowa’s members of Congress react to Supreme Court overturning Roe v. Wade

June 25, 2022
State Government

Post Roe, state elected officials pledge abortion debate in Iowa

June 25, 2022
Hendrickson & Williams: Governor Reynolds’ Tax Reform Ideas are Pro-Growth
State Government

Iowa to allocate $100M in federal funding for school safety

June 16, 2022
Politics

Several Republican incumbent lawmakers lose primaries

June 8, 2022
Hendrickson: Fiscal Conservatism Works
Opinion

Hendrickson: A pro-taxpayer budget

June 8, 2022
Next Post
National Museum of China by Shuaizhi Tian.

Miller-Meeks: Holding the Chinese Communist Party accountable

mining excavation on a mountain

Ernst: Securing critical minerals is essential for America’s national security

Sign-Up For Our Daily Updates

Get The Iowa Torch right in your inbox!

Please wait...

Thank you for signing up!

Recommended Articles

Iowa Senate Judiciary Committee Approves Gun Rights Amendment

Iowa Senate Judiciary Committee Approves Gun Rights Amendment

January 26, 2021
Klein Announces He Will Not Run for Re-Election to the Iowa House in 2022

Klein Announces He Will Not Run for Re-Election to the Iowa House in 2022

January 26, 2022
Axne Calls for President Trump’s Cabinet to Invoke the 25th Amendment

Axne Pushes Loan Relief for Rural Communities with First Bill of 2021

January 28, 2021

Popular Stories

  • Schultz: Governor Highlights Successes in Western Iowa

    Reynolds to ask Iowa Courts to reconsider recent abortion rulings

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Iowa employers say attracting a quality workforce is a top priority

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Axne attacks Nunn in first campaign ad

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Several Republican incumbent lawmakers lose primaries

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Bill Gustoff Announces Campaign for Iowa House District 40

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

The Iowa Torch

The Iowa Torch​ is a for-profit, news organization that focuses on political news as it relates to Iowans

Categories

  • Education
  • Federal Government
  • Iowa History
  • Local Government
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • State Government
  • Uncategorized
  • Uncategorized

Newsletter

Please wait...

Thank you for signing up!

© 2022 The Iowa Torch, a publication of 4:15 Communications, LLC.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • State Government
  • Federal Government
  • Local Government
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Opinion

© 2022 The Iowa Torch, a publication of 4:15 Communications, LLC.