• About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Saturday, May 31, 2025
The Iowa Torch
  • Home
  • State Government
  • Federal Government
  • Local Government
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • State Government
  • Federal Government
  • Local Government
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Opinion
The Iowa Torch
The Iowa Torch
No Result
View All Result
Home Federal Government

Judge rules gender quota for state judicial nominating commission unconstitutional

U.S. District Judge Stephanie Rose said a gender-based quota for Iowa's State Judicial Nominating Commission members is unconstitutional.

Kim JarrettbyKim Jarrett
January 18, 2024
in Federal Government, State Government
Reading Time: 2 mins read

United States Courthouse for the Southern District of Iowa in Des Moines, Iowa.
Photo by Shane Vander Hart

(The Center Square) – A U.S. district judge said a gender-based quota for Iowa’s State Judicial Nominating Commission members is unconstitutional.

RELATED POSTS

Reynolds signs bill enacting flat tax in 2025

Reynolds joins bipartisan opposition to Biden Administration’s Space Force proposal

Iowa lawmakers enact flat tax for 2025

Former state representative Chuck Hurley sued Iowa State Court Administrator Robert Gast over a law passed in the late 80s. The 17-member commission consists of nine members that are appointed. The other eight members are elected – two from each of the state’s four congressional districts.

The law requires that the two members of each congressional district be of different genders. This bars Hurley from running for the commission in 2025 because the open seat is currently held by a woman, according to the Pacific Legal Foundation, which is representing Hurley in the case.

The commission reviews and selects nominees for the Iowa Supreme Court and the Iowa Court of Appeals, according to the lawsuit. As a legislator, Hurley served on the Iowa House Judiciary Committee and worked in the community in various capacities, including as an attorney, according to PLF.

ADVERTISEMENT

U.S. District Court Judge Stephanie M. Rose said the law was passed to address past discrimination.

“However, the Court cannot find the law is substantially related to any current discrimination, nor can the Court find that the law is tailored to accomplish any of the government’s other stated objectives,” Rose said in the order provided by PLF. “Therefore, the Court must find that Iowa Code § 46.2 does not survive intermediate scrutiny.”

The case also involved two other plaintiffs, Rachel Raak Law and Micah Broekemeier, who were planning to run for seats on the commission in 2023.

“We are hopeful that the Iowa legislature takes this cue from the Court and repeals the state’s remaining gender balance laws,” said Laura D’Agostino, lead attorney. “We are also hopeful that other states across the country take notice. PLF has filed multiple lawsuits challenging race- and sex-based quotas on government boards and commissions. This opinion puts those, and others states on notice that that these types board quotas are plainly unconstitutional.”

Attorney General Brenna Bird’s office, which represented Gast in the case, did not return a message seeking comment.

Tags: Brenna BirdChuck HurleyLaura D'AgostinoPacific Legal FoundationRobert GastState Judicial Nominating CommissionStephanie RoseU.S. District Court for the Southern District of Iowa
ShareTweetShare
ADVERTISEMENT
Previous Post

Attorney General Bird sues TikTok claiming social media app misleads parents

Next Post

Iowa Senate panel advances parental opt-in for sex education bill

Kim Jarrett

Kim Jarrett

Kim Jarrett is the associate editor of The Center Square. Jarrett's career spans over 30 years with stops in radio, print and television. She has won awards from both the Georgia Press Association and the Georgia Association of Broadcasters.

Related Posts

Hinson: Use biofuels to bring down the cost of gas today
Federal Government

EPA issues emergency fuel waiver for E15 sales

April 19, 2024
Bird joins 15-state coalition demanding Bank of America stop debanking
State Government

Bird joins 15-state coalition demanding Bank of America stop debanking

April 18, 2024
Iowa farmer challenges constitutionality of ‘Swampbuster’ Law
News

Iowa farmer challenges constitutionality of ‘Swampbuster’ Law

April 17, 2024
Sand: Iowans must stand with victims
Opinion

Sand: Iowans must stand with victims

April 16, 2024
Reynolds signs bill protecting ownership of Iowa farmland
State Government

Reynolds signs bill protecting ownership of Iowa farmland

April 10, 2024
State Government

Reynolds signs bill eliminating gender balance requirement for appointed commissions and boards

April 5, 2024
Next Post
Iowa Senate panel advances parental opt-in for sex education bill

Iowa Senate panel advances parental opt-in for sex education bill

Hendricks: American soil should remain in American hands

Recommended Articles

Ted Cruz to Headline Hinson Fundraiser in August

Ted Cruz to Headline Hinson Fundraiser in August

July 21, 2021
Schultz: Governor Highlights Successes in Western Iowa

Hendrickson: Governor Kim Reynolds has a mandate

November 15, 2022
Ernst Expresses Concern About Trump’s Upcoming Senate Impeachment Trial

Ernst Urges Census Bureau to Get Data to States

March 2, 2021

Popular Stories

  • Rozenboom: Reflecting on the First Week of the 2021 Legislative Session

    Rozenboom: Reflecting on the First Week of the 2021 Legislative Session

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Hendrickson: John Calvin’s contribution to liberty

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Iowa Schools Now Required to Lead Students in Pledge of Allegiance

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Bousselot Announces He Will Run for the Iowa Senate

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Three LGTBQ Books with Sexually Explicit Material Pulled from Waukee School

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
The Iowa Torch

The Iowa Torch​ is a for-profit, news organization that focuses on political news as it relates to Iowans

Categories

  • Current Events
  • Education
  • Federal Government
  • Iowa History
  • Local Government
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • State Government

Newsletter

© 2022 The Iowa Torch, a publication of 4:15 Communications, LLC.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • State Government
  • Federal Government
  • Local Government
  • Politics
  • Education
  • Opinion

© 2022 The Iowa Torch, a publication of 4:15 Communications, LLC.